Growth Analyser Growth Analyser

Compare funds

Pick up to 10 funds. Compare funds from the same category for a fair reading.

Carnelian Liquid Fund · Direct ✕Tata Liquid Fund · Direct ✕

Growth of ₹10,000

Basics

Carnelian Liquid FundTata Liquid Fund
CategoryLiquidLiquid
PlanDirectDirect
Fund houseCarnelianTata
NAV₹1,005.6728₹4,535.9274
NAV date21 Nov 202620 Nov 2026
History1 months13.9 years
Expense ratio0.2%0.2%
StarsNot rated★★★★★
Growth Score—63.80

Returns

Carnelian Liquid FundTata Liquid Fund
1 month+0.42%+0.56%
3 months—+1.55%
6 months—+3.29%
YTD—+5.83%
1 year—+6.54%
3 years (CAGR)—+6.92%
5 years (CAGR)—+6.46%
10 years (CAGR)—+6.12%
Since launch+0.46%+6.85%

Risk

Carnelian Liquid FundTata Liquid Fund
Volatility—0.2%
Downside volatility—0.1%
Sharpe—1.80
Sortino—3.75
Calmar—661.48
Return / risk—29.70
Deepest fall+0.00%−0.23%
Days to recover—3
Below its high+0.00%+0.00%

Against benchmark

Carnelian Liquid FundTata Liquid Fund
Alpha——
Beta——
R²——
Up capture——
Down capture——
Tracking error——
Information ratio——
Treynor——

Consistency

Carnelian Liquid FundTata Liquid Fund
Best 1-year—+9.98%
Middle 1-year—+7.08%
Worst 1-year—+3.23%
1-year periods with a loss—0.0%
Middle 3-year—+6.98%
Positive months—100.0%
Best day+0.03%+0.12%
Worst day+0.01%−0.01%
Worst 5% day+0.01%+0.01%
Positive days100.0%99.4%
NAVs a year33314

SIP of ₹10,000 a month

Carnelian Liquid FundTata Liquid Fund
5-year XIRR—+6.76%
5-year value—₹7,14,232
3-year XIRR—+6.70%
1-year XIRR—+6.57%

Holdings overlap i

Overlap needs the monthly portfolio filing of at least two of these funds; not loaded yet.

Search Growth