Growth Analyser Growth Analyser

Compare funds

Pick up to 10 funds. Compare funds from the same category for a fair reading.

HDFC Silver ETF · Regular ✕Edelweiss Silver ETF · Regular ✕

Growth of ₹10,000

Basics

HDFC Silver ETFEdelweiss Silver ETF
CategorySilver ETFsSilver ETFs
PlanRegularRegular
Fund houseHDFCEdelweiss
NAV₹145.9194₹152.6180
NAV date20 Nov 202620 Nov 2026
History4.2 years3.0 years
Expense ratio0.5%0.5%
StarsNot ratedNot rated
Growth Score——

Returns

HDFC Silver ETFEdelweiss Silver ETF
1 month−26.15%−26.12%
3 months−35.33%−35.22%
6 months−42.47%−42.31%
YTD−33.29%−33.02%
1 year−1.79%−1.40%
3 years (CAGR)+26.75%+26.50%
5 years (CAGR)——
10 years (CAGR)——
Since launch+27.76%+26.50%

Risk

HDFC Silver ETFEdelweiss Silver ETF
Volatility46.9%45.9%
Downside volatility24.4%23.5%
Sharpe0.430.44
Sortino0.830.85
Calmar0.450.45
Return / risk0.570.58
Deepest fall−59.43%−59.26%
Days to recover——
Below its high−59.43%−59.26%

Against benchmark

HDFC Silver ETFEdelweiss Silver ETF
Alpha−0.93%−0.01%
Beta1.010.99
R²99.1%100.0%
Up capture101.8%99.3%
Down capture104.4%99.2%
Tracking error4.4%0.4%
Information ratio−0.16−0.46
Treynor0.170.19

Consistency

HDFC Silver ETFEdelweiss Silver ETF
Best 1-year+306.70%+307.32%
Middle 1-year+28.24%+50.13%
Worst 1-year−2.06%−1.40%
1-year periods with a loss1.0%0.2%
Middle 3-year+45.41%—
Positive months58.3%58.3%
Best day+9.04%+9.05%
Worst day−20.04%−20.02%
Worst 5% day−3.39%−3.05%
Positive days54.1%54.6%
NAVs a year248248

SIP of ₹10,000 a month

HDFC Silver ETFEdelweiss Silver ETF
5-year XIRR——
5-year value——
3-year XIRR+20.34%—
1-year XIRR−47.92%−47.64%

Holdings overlap i

Overlap needs the monthly portfolio filing of at least two of these funds; not loaded yet.

Search Growth