Growth Analyser Growth Analyser

Compare funds

Pick up to 10 funds. Compare funds from the same category for a fair reading.

ICICI Prudential Commodities Fund · Direct ✕Franklin Asian Equity Fund · Direct ✕

Growth of ₹10,000

Basics

ICICI Prudential Commodities FundFranklin Asian Equity Fund
CategorySectoral / ThematicSectoral / Thematic
PlanDirectDirect
Fund houseICICI PruFranklin
NAV₹48.8800₹45.3436
NAV date19 Nov 202619 Nov 2026
History7.1 years13.9 years
Expense ratio1.0%1.2%
Stars★★★★★★★★★★
Growth Score56.2064.90

Returns

ICICI Prudential Commodities FundFranklin Asian Equity Fund
1 month+1.05%−1.78%
3 months−5.33%−8.66%
6 months−5.31%−3.66%
YTD−0.24%+16.21%
1 year+3.43%+20.98%
3 years (CAGR)+13.74%+19.44%
5 years (CAGR)+14.61%+6.81%
10 years (CAGR)—+10.32%
Since launch+25.05%+9.32%

Risk

ICICI Prudential Commodities FundFranklin Asian Equity Fund
Volatility17.1%17.7%
Downside volatility11.1%10.4%
Sharpe0.420.73
Sortino0.651.25
Calmar0.741.37
Return / risk0.811.10
Deepest fall−41.20%−40.20%
Days to recover1361074
Below its high−8.89%−11.70%

Against benchmark

ICICI Prudential Commodities FundFranklin Asian Equity Fund
Alpha+0.56%+10.64%
Beta0.880.52
R²86.3%22.0%
Up capture93.3%70.6%
Down capture90.2%1.9%
Tracking error6.7%17.4%
Information ratio−0.050.47
Treynor0.070.25

Consistency

ICICI Prudential Commodities FundFranklin Asian Equity Fund
Best 1-year+197.93%+71.57%
Middle 1-year+22.25%+10.63%
Worst 1-year−7.87%−32.93%
1-year periods with a loss7.5%26.1%
Middle 3-year+22.19%+8.99%
Positive months61.1%58.3%
Best day+4.04%+5.04%
Worst day−7.99%−6.66%
Worst 5% day−1.98%−1.67%
Positive days55.7%56.9%
NAVs a year247247

SIP of ₹10,000 a month

ICICI Prudential Commodities FundFranklin Asian Equity Fund
5-year XIRR+12.71%+15.08%
5-year value₹8,30,557₹8,81,338
3-year XIRR+6.81%+19.77%
1-year XIRR−3.08%+4.81%

Holdings overlap i

Overlap needs the monthly portfolio filing of at least two of these funds; not loaded yet.

Search Growth