Growth Analyser Growth Analyser

Compare funds

Pick up to 10 funds. Compare funds from the same category for a fair reading.

Tata Resources & Energy Fund · Direct ✕ICICI Prudential Commodities Fund · Direct ✕

Growth of ₹10,000

Basics

Tata Resources & Energy FundICICI Prudential Commodities Fund
CategorySectoral / ThematicSectoral / Thematic
PlanDirectDirect
Fund houseTataICICI Pru
AUM₹1,417 Cr₹4,145 Cr
NAV₹55.2908₹48.7400
NAV date20 Nov 202620 Nov 2026
History—7.1 years
Expense ratio0.8%1.0%
StarsNot rated★★★★★
Growth Score—55.00

AUM: AMFI's average assets under management for July - September 2026, in ₹ crore, for the whole fund (Direct and Regular, Growth and IDCW added up). The same source and period for every fund, so the figures compare.

Returns

Tata Resources & Energy FundICICI Prudential Commodities Fund
1 month—+0.76%
3 months—−5.74%
6 months—−5.87%
YTD—−0.53%
1 year—+3.35%
3 years (CAGR)—+13.70%
5 years (CAGR)—+14.54%
10 years (CAGR)——
Since launch—+24.99%

Risk

Tata Resources & Energy FundICICI Prudential Commodities Fund
Volatility—17.0%
Downside volatility—11.1%
Sharpe—0.42
Sortino—0.65
Calmar—0.74
Return / risk—0.80
Deepest fall—−41.20%
Days to recover—136
Below its high—−9.15%

Against benchmark

Tata Resources & Energy FundICICI Prudential Commodities Fund
Alpha—+0.16%
Beta—0.88
R²—86.1%
Up capture—92.3%
Down capture—90.8%
Tracking error—6.7%
Information ratio—−0.11
Treynor—0.07

Consistency

Tata Resources & Energy FundICICI Prudential Commodities Fund
Best 1-year—+197.93%
Middle 1-year—+22.17%
Worst 1-year—−7.87%
1-year periods with a loss—7.5%
Middle 3-year—+22.19%
Positive months—61.1%
Best day—+4.04%
Worst day—−7.99%
Worst 5% day—−1.98%
Positive days—55.6%
NAVs a year—247

SIP of ₹10,000 a month

Tata Resources & Energy FundICICI Prudential Commodities Fund
5-year XIRR—+12.59%
5-year value—₹8,28,179
3-year XIRR—+6.61%
1-year XIRR—−3.53%

Holdings overlap i

Tata Resources & Energy FundICICI Prudential Commodities Fund
Tata Resources & Energy Fund
Direct · filing Oct 2026
—29%
ICICI Prudential Commodities Fund
Direct · filing Oct 2026
29%—

Share of money in the same stocks, by weight. Above 50% means much of one fund repeats the other.

Tata Resources & Energy Fund and ICICI Prudential Commodities Fund

Overlap
29.2%
smaller weight of each shared stock, added up
Stocks in common
16
of 42 and 49
Weight in common
40% · 59%
of each fund's money
Filings compared
Oct 2026 · Oct 2026
same month
Common stockTata Resources & Energy FundICICI Prudential Commodities FundCounts toward overlap
Vedanta Aluminium Metal Limited4.57%6.05%4.57%
UltraTech Cement Limited5.83%4.18%4.18%
Jindal Steel Limited2.88%8.14%2.88%
JSW Steel Limited2.82%7.02%2.82%
Navin Fluorine International Limited2.62%3.78%2.62%
Tata Steel Limited4.17%1.94%1.94%
Ambuja Cements Limited2.89%1.90%1.90%
Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Limited1.67%9.02%1.67%
Bharat Petroleum Corporation Limited3.22%1.32%1.32%
Hindalco Industries Limited1.30%4.52%1.30%
APL Apollo Tubes Limited1.21%3.01%1.21%
Jindal Stainless Limited0.89%4.51%0.89%
Hindustan Zinc Limited2.29%0.69%0.69%
Aarti Industries Limited0.66%2.80%0.66%
Gujarat Fluorochemicals Limited1.92%0.44%0.44%
MOIL LTD1.44%0.14%0.14%
16 stocks40.4%59.5%29.2%

Only in Tata Resources & Energy Fund (26)

Adani Power Limited4.99%
Adani Energy Solutions Limited4.97%
Reliance Industries Limited4.39%
Oil & Natural Gas Corporation Limited3.74%
NTPC Limited3.34%
Ganesha Ecosphere Ltd.3.02%
Coal India Limited2.93%
West Coast Paper Mills Limited2.23%
Inox India Limited2.10%
NHPC Limited2.05%
INDO-MIM Ltd.2.04%
CCL Products (India) Limited1.97%
DEE DEVELOPMENT ENGINEERS LTD1.91%
Bayer Cropscience Limited1.78%
Grasim Industries Limited1.57%
Fujiyama Power Systems Limited1.47%
CESC Limited1.41%
Ellenbarrie Industrial Gases Limited1.32%
Nuvoco Vistas Corporation Limited1.32%
NMDC Limited1.27%
Sumitomo Chemical India Limited1.25%
Power Grid Corporation of India Limited1.20%
Oil India Limited1.10%
Indian Oil Corporation Limited1.08%
Shree Cement Limited0.90%

and 1 smaller holdings (0.8% of the fund).

Only in ICICI Prudential Commodities Fund (33)

UPL Limited3.96%
Freeport-McMoRan Inc3.74%
Vedanta Limited3.72%
Usha Martin Limited3.61%
National Aluminium Co Limited2.56%
Southern Copper Corp2.29%
Paradeep Phosphates Limited2.13%
Steel Authority of India Limited2.03%
SRF Limited1.69%
Cameco Corp1.66%
Deepak Fertilizers and Petrochemicals Corporation Limited1.47%
Deepak Nitrite Limited1.36%
Camlin Fine Sciences Ltd.1.32%
Neogen Chemicals Limited0.98%
Laxmi Organic Industries Limited0.80%
Atul Limited0.68%
Sagar Cements Ltd.0.66%
Graphite India Limited0.57%
Archean Chemical Industries Limited0.44%
Vedanta Iron And Steel Limited0.36%
Thirumalai Chemicals Ltd0.35%
National Organic Chemical Ltd.0.30%
Gujarat Narmada Valley Fertilizers and Chemicals Limited0.26%
Tatva Chintan Pharma Chem Limited0.24%
PI Industries Limited0.24%

and 8 smaller holdings (1.2% of the fund).

Method: from each fund's latest monthly portfolio filing, shares only (Indian and foreign equity; bonds, cash and derivatives are left out). Overlap adds up, for every stock both hold, the smaller of the two weights.

Sectors and company size

Tata Resources & Energy FundICICI Prudential Commodities Fund
Large companies58.2%39.5%
Mid companies11.0%27.5%
Small companies25.2%23.4%
Top 10 holdings42.2%54.9%
Largest sectorPower 18%Ferrous Metals 24%

Search Growth